COMMENTARY 862.2: The Disease of Low Expectations

by Michael Josephson on January 13, 2014

in Commentaries, The Nature of Character

The serious damage done to our economy, social institutions, and personal relationships by widespread cheating and dishonesty is bad enough. But widespread acceptance of such behavior as inevitable threatens to make our future a lot worse. In effect, our culture is being infected by a disease: the disease of low expectations.

The disease is manifested by the corrosive assumption that human nature can’t be expected to withstand pressures or temptations. In other words, when there’s a conflict between self-interest and moral principles, self-interest – in fact, short-term self-interest – will generally prevail.

Thus, whenever a politician lies to get elected, a student cheats to get into college, or an executive commits fraud to save a job or earn a bonus, we blame the system rather than the individual. Under the influence of the disease of low expectations, an increasing army of apologists argue that both the carrot and the stick – previously thought to be valid motivating techniques – should be condemned and eliminated as corrupting influences that create irresistible pressures to cheat.

A school superintendent in Iowa once told me, “Cheating isn’t the problem; it’s the way we test.” We can’t expect students not to cheat, he implied, especially when the stakes are so high.

I wonder whether he would be as comfortable with a similar explanation of recent corporate scandals: “Fraudulent accounting isn’t the problem; it’s the way we compensate executives.”

Don’t buy into this dreadfully pessimistic and perverted perspective about human nature. Cheating is wrong and harmful. Integrity is real and possible. It just takes character.

This is Michael Josephson reminding you that character counts.

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

Chris Smithhisler January 17, 2014 at 6:04 am

I wholeheartedly agree! I work with college students on a daily basis and I have found that if we set high expectations for the most part they will rise to the occasion. Now there is the exception but that doesn’t mean we lower expectations at that point. Thanks for this commentary!


Anonymous July 7, 2014 at 10:17 am

i think this content is being used without permission
just wanted to let you know!


Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: